5 Key Differences between the Stochastic RSI and Stochastic

What is the Stochastics Oscillator?

While there are many oscillators, the Stochastics and Stochastic RSI are two of the most popular technical indicators.

Bonus: Download the free Tradingsim day trading ebook with over 10,000 words of trading strategies and techniques you can use to trade stocks, futures and bitcoin!

So, why do we need two indicators with practically the same name?

Let's go deep into the key differences between the indicators and how you can make money trading with these tools.

The Stochastics oscillator or Stochs for short is a typical range bound oscillator measuring price momentum. As with other oscillators, the Stochastics displays the location of the closing price relative to the high and low range over a specific period of time.

The Stochastics oscillator’s main purpose is to look for overbought and oversold levels which signifies rising and falling momentum. You can use both indicators to identify trending and range bound markets.

History of Stochastics Oscillator

The Stochastics oscillator was developed by George Lane in the 50’s and according to Lane, the Stochastics oscillator was a credible way to measure price momentum.

More importantly, Lane believe that changes in momentum often preceded changes in price, in a way making the Stochastics oscillator a type of a leading indicator for price changes by measuring momentum. Lane attributed this theory by comparing the way a rocket lifts off. A famous quote from Lane is that before a Rocket can change direction and turn down; the rocker’s momentum needs to slow. Similarly when price changes, momentum needs to slow.

Settings

Stochastics can work in both range and trending markets. It just comes down to how you interpret readings between 0 and 100.

The Stochastics oscillator is comprised of the first line known as %K which displays the current closing prices in relation to the defined high and low period. The second line known as %D is a simple moving average of the %K. The most common setting for the Stochastics oscillator is 14, 3, 3 or simply 14, 3. This simply indicates a 14-period look-back and a 3 period SMA for %K, which is %D.

The chart below shows the typical Stochastics configuration on a price chart.

Example Stochastics indicator with 14, 3, 3, Set up

Example Stochastics indicator with 14, 3, 3, Set up

Additional Types of Stochastics

Besides the 14, 3 or the 14, 3, 3 setting of the Stochastics oscillator, there are other versions such as the full Stochastics and the slow Stochastics.


The slow Stochastics is less sensitive to momentum and as a result shows a much smoother output. Therefore, the slow Stochastics is better for long-term trend analysis.

Conversely, the fast Stochastics is more sensitive to price momentum and can better signal short-term trend changes.

Trading with Stochastics

The most common way to trade with Stochastics is to combine the indicator with chart patterns and trend lines.

Let me break this down further.

For example, if price closed in the upper half of the range for the past 14 period’s high and low, this is reflected by the %K line rising. This also signals increased momentum and thus more buying pressure in the market.

Similarly, when price closes in the lower half of the range of the past 14 periods, then the %K line falls or slopes down, indicating weakening momentum or increase selling pressure.

The %D is the simple moving average of the %K and similar to the general rules of moving averages, when the %K cuts across the %D line, buy and sell signals are generated or the momentum is seen to increase and decrease even further.

When you combine Stochastic readings with the trend you can also identify buying and selling opportunities.

The chart below depicts how the Stochastics %K line (and thus %D) rise and fall in relation to closing prices.

Stochastics %K and %D lines indicating rising and falling momentum

Stochastics %K and %D lines indicating rising and falling momentum

What is the Stochastic RSI oscillator?

The Stocahstic RSI indicator or Stoch RSI is an advanced version of the Stochastics oscillator. The primary difference being that the Stochastics RSI indicator is known as an indicator of an indicator. The Stoch RSI was developed by Tushar Chande and Stanley Kroll and the indicator was introduced in 1994 in a book called The New Technical Trader.

Stochastics RSI Oscillator

Stochastics RSI Oscillator

The Stochastics RSI indicator provides a stochastic calculation of the RSI (Relative Strength Index) which is another momentum based indicator. The main difference here being that, the Stochastics RSI measures the RSI, relative to its RSI’s high and low range over the specified period of time.

You can see by now the following relationship.

  • RSI indicator is based on price
  • The Stochastic RSI is based on RSI

Thus, the Stochastic RSI is basically two steps away from price. As with all momentum indicators, the Stochastic RSI indicator oscillates between fixed values.

Why Create Another Version of the Stochastic Indicator?

The basic premise behind developing the Stochastic RSI is because the RSI is able to oscillate between overbought and oversold values of 80 and 20 for extended periods of time without reaching the extreme levels of 100 and 0.

Generally, the RSI has overbought and oversold values of 70 and 30. Traders look to enter a trade when the RSI is oversold and exit or trim their positions when the RSI is overbought. But when the RSI starts to move within this range, traders are often left on the sidelines.

In order to address this issue, Chande and Kroll designed the Stochastics RSI to increase sensitivity to the RSI and generate more overbought and oversold signals. However, due to the fact that the Stochastic RSI is an indicator of an indicator, there can be a significant lag between the signals generated by the indicator and the price chart.

Furthermore, the Stochastics RSI can getchoppy when markets are range bound and which can lead to false signals.

Settings

 

The Stochastics RSI values are generally a 14 period look back of the RSI and 3 period SMA. It is commonly referred to as the 14, 14, 3, 3 setting.

When trading with the Stocahstics RSI, there are some key factors to bear in mind.

The Stochastics RSI measures the value of the RSI, relative to the range from the user defined look back period.

Secondly, you enter the number of periods for the Stochastics RSI directly in the settings.

Finally, there are some key values from the Stochastics RSI oscillator.

  • RSI is at the lowest point when 14-day Stochastic RSI = 0
  • The RSI is at the highest point when 14-day Stochastics RSI = 1
  • RSI is at the middle when 14-day Stochastics RSI = 0.5
  • The RSI is near the low point when 14-day Stochastics = 0.2
  • RSI is near the high when 14-day Stochastics = 0.8

Interpretation of the Stochastics RSI Oscillator

Overbought and oversold levels: A Stochastic RSI reading above 0.80 is overbought, while an indicator reading below 0.20 is oversold.

Trends: When the Stochastics RSI oscillator is consistently above 0.50, it reflects an uptrend in prices and when the Stochastics RSI oscillator is consistently below 0.50, it reflects a downtrend in prices


An important point to remember about the Stochastic RSI is that the original indicator did not have the SMA of the %K. However more and more technical charting platforms have started offering the SMA setting of the %K as well making it look similar to the regular Stochastics oscillator.

Most charting platforms set the range of the Stochastics RSI to 0 – 100 instead of the original 0 and 1.

Stochastic RSI Indicator showing Overbought and Oversold signals

Stochastic RSI Indicator showing Overbought and Oversold signals

The above chart shows the Stochastics RSI indicator without the %D or the SMA of the %K. The platform is showing the 80 and 20 values versus the 0.8 and 0.2. Regardless, whenever the Stochastics RSI rises above 0.20 in range bound markets - price rallies.

Conversely, price can fall when the Stochastics RSI falls below the 80 level.

Five key differences between the Stochastic RSI and Stochastic

Now that we know how the Stochastic RSI and the stochastic oscillator works, here are the five key differences between the two oscillators.

#1 - #3 Different Base of Measurement

The Stochastics oscillator measures price momentum and is based on the closing price as defined by the back period.

The Stochastic RSI on the other hand measures the momentum of the RSI and is based on the closing price of RSI, relative to the user defined high and low range from the RSI’s look back period.

The Stochastics oscillator is based directly from price, whereas the Stochastics RSI is an indicator of an indicator meaning that it measures the momentum of the RSI, which is based on price. In other words, the Stochastics RSI is simply two steps away from price and can therefore lag significantly

The regular Stochastics oscillator moves between fixed values of 0 and 100 with 80 indicating overbought level and 20 indicating oversold levels. The Stochastic RSI on the other hand oscillates between 0 and 1 where 0.80 indicates overbought levels and 0.20 indicates oversold levels

#4 Different Scale

Unlike the Stochastics oscillator, you can use .50 as a filter with the Stochastic RSI. Therefore, if the Stochastic RSI continually plots above 0.50, the market is in an uptrend and when the Stochastics RSI plots below 0.50, the market isin a downtrend. Most charting platforms now generally use the Stochastics RSI values to oscillate between 0 and 100 instead of the original 0 and 1 values.

#5 More Signals

While the Stochastics oscillator is used to measure price momentum and overbought/oversold levels, the Stochastics RSI is designed to be more sensitive and triggers a lot more overbought and oversold levels in comparison to the traditional Stochastics oscillator.

The chart below shows a comparison between the Stochastics oscillator and the Stochastics RSI. You can see how the Stochastics RSI triggers more overbought and oversold levels compared to the traditional Stochastics indicator.

Stochastics vs. Stochastics RSI indicator

Stochastics vs. Stochastics RSI indicator

Where can Stochastics Fail You?


Like most of my articles, the post would not be complete if I did not share with you how the indicator can absolutely betray you in the real-world.

Next we will cover the two ways the Stochastics will commit an act of treason likely on a daily basis.

#1 - Stochastic RSI Crosses Above and Below 50

I totally get your desire to want to place more trades. However, with each new trade comes the risk of losing on each one. Well, the 50 level is focus for traders without a doubt. However, are traders willing to jump in at the 50 level or the extremes of 80 and 20?

I think it goes without saying you will likely have less participants at the 50.

So, here is where things can get tricky.

If you just trade blindly on the crosses of 5o first you will always be in the market.

Why is that a problem. First, the market does not always provide trading opportunities every second of the day.

Next, commissions will eat you alive. The last thing you want to do is make your broker rich on the back of your hard work.

The third reason you do not want to trade these crosses of the 50 blindly are the number of false signals. Let me further illustrate this point by looking at some price action.

Chop Chop and More Chop

Chop Chop and More Chop

I'm not going to waste my time or yours analyzing each trade signal from the crosses above and below 50 in the chart. Just think about you placing and closing each one of these trades.

The thing people do not talk about enough is the psychological strain you will go through placing these trades. I do not care who you are, at some point you will start to pass on trading opportunities. As you know, once you do start selecting setups instead of taking each trade, the game is over.

Point is, this is not a strategy that will turn a profit in the long run.

#2 - False Sell Signals

False Stochastic Sell Signals

False Stochastic Sell Signals

In the above chart, notice how the stock continues to climb higher after each reading over 80. This is just a prime example of how you cannot blindly short just because the indicator is over 80.

You have to combine other indicators and or chart patterns to validate the sell signal.

The last thing you ever want to do is continue to average down as a position goes against you. I once continued to buy into each reading below 20.

Little did I know, the stock would trend lower all day as I averaged down 5 times into the close. Needless to say it was a $4,250 dollar lesson that I will never forget.

In Conclusion

It's really going to come down to what best fits your trading style. If you are the kind of trader that likes more signals, the Stochastic RSI will meet this need.

The truth of the matter is you just need to pick one and master it. Another option could be to look at both indicators and pinpoint when there is divergence between the two. This could also help you identify trading opportunities.

Remember to not place too much faith in oversold/overbought readings when the market is trending. Again, oscillators will trigger more false signals if a stock is trending.

The absolute sweet spot for using the Stochastics RSI or Stochasitic indicators is on low volatility stocks. I know what you are saying, "low volatility stocks are boring".

To be honest, that is a true statement. You are not going to have a 20% intraday move trading Microsoft. However, these large stocks with large floats have predictable moves. This level or predictability bodes will for indicators like the Stochastics which require a clean high low price range.

Additional Resources

Here is a great video on YouTube from Investor Trading Academy that covers oscillators in general. This is a short video which can wet your appetite a little more in these types of indicators.

Also, please be sure to check out more posts on oscillators from Tradingsim. See which oscillator works best for your trading style.

Al Hill Administrator
Co-Founder Tradingsim
Al Hill is one of the co-founders of Tradingsim. He has over 18 years of day trading experience in both the U.S. and Nikkei markets. On a daily basis Al applies his deep skills in systems integration and design strategy to develop features to help retail traders become profitable. When Al is not working on Tradingsim, he can be found spending time with family and friends.
follow me



See How Tradingsim Works